Sex Diaries Vol. 27: How A 21-Year Old Student Accidentally Had A Threesome With Two Sisters

Meet James, a 21-year-old student at a university in Lagos. In the course of reuniting with his former sex buddy, he unintentionally participates in a threesome with Jennifer and her friend, Amy. Unbeknownst to him, the pair are sisters. He shares his story in today’s sex diary:

Backstory

It was a lazy Friday for me. At noon, I woke up starving and decided to go to Dominoes to order pizza. I walked in and joined the queue. It was nearly my turn to my order when I looked at the queue adjacent to me and saw a pretty lady ready to make her order. I took a quick look at her and from what I saw, she seemed like my type. After she got her order taken, she went to a table to wait for her pizza to get ready. Luckily, the chairs around her were free. After my order was taken, I approached her, introduced myself, complimented her and asked if I could join her. She introduced herself, returned the compliment and we chatted a little until her order was ready. After she got her pizza, we exchanged numbers, she said bye and left. I called her later on in the night and we had an even better chat. From the phone call, she seemed to be ticking off some of my boxes. We continued speaking. The following weekend, I took her out on a date to a restaurant on the island. The date went well and she sealed it with a kiss. We continued getting to know each other and our feelings got stronger. A month later, I invited her to my place and we had sex for the first time. The sex was really good I came twice. Since then, we started fucking often and that’s how our relationship went from ‘just buddies’ to ‘sex buddies’. 3 months into our ’friends with benefits’ relationship, Jennifer told me she was moving to Abuja. I was heart broken especially since I had plans to ask her to officially be my girlfriend. We met a couple days later for one more intense sex before she leaves Lagos. It was probably the last time I would have sex with her until we meet again.

D-day

Jennifer and I remained in touch while she was in Abuja though not as much compared to when she was in Lagos. On a Wednesday, I woke up late and started doing the house chores. In the evening, while I was organizing my dad’s room, I got a text from Jennifer saying she was around and close by. I happily told her to come over. I had nothing on but a shirt and my towel. In the next 10 minutes, she arrives. I opened the gate for her, gave her a big hug and said hi to her friend Amy. I was shocked she came with someone to my house (usually it’s just her and I alone in the house) but I shrugged it off. They came in and I took them to my room so we could chat. A few minutes later, I went to the bathroom to quickly take a shower. I got out and remained in my towel and sat close to Jennifer on the bed. Normally, Jennifer and I would have fucked but her friend being around made me  unsure. Jennifer and I started talking dirty and it seemed Amy didn’t mind. I was still extremely confused as to what was going on. Jennifer kissed me and we started making out in front of Amy. While kissing her neck, I whispered to Jennifer telling her that her friend is here and it doesn’t feel right if we made out. I told her it would make Amy uncomfortable. She said “it wouldn’t” and I asked her if she was sure, she said “yes”. We started making out and I asked Amy if she wanted to join in, she chuckled. I let them know I was going to switch off the light and I did. After doing that, I went towards Amy and started kissing her just so she doesn’t feel alone. Jennifer started taking off her clothes and I took off Amy’s clothes while I kissed her. Next, Jennifer began fingering herself slowly and moaning while she watched suck Amy’s breasts. I laid beside Amy on the bed, ran my hands down, between her thighs and fingered her while we kissed. Jennifer comes over, gives me a quick hand job before putting my dick in her mouth. She went ahead to suck my dick slowly and joined me to finger Amy. After that, I stood up, went to the bathroom. I went to the mirror to converse with myself and motivate myself. I kept telling myself that it was the first time I was having a threesome with two girls. I sighed and decided to finish up what we started. I went back to the room, pulled out my chair to watch them make out. I got excited watching Jennifer eat Amy out. Amy stood up, picked me up from the chair and took me to the bed. She laid me down, sat on my dick and rode me slowly while Jennifer caressed Amy’s titties. Amy and I moaned while I watched her breasts bounce as she hopped on my dick. Next, I pull her to the side, and she got in the dougie position (the only sex style that makes me cum). I went behind her and thrust my dick in. Amy was wet and my dick slid in easily. I kept thrusting in then I stopped. I went closer to Jennifer, placed her in the dougie position and fucked her from behind. I continue taking turns to fuck them until I came.

At some point it was too dark for me to know what was going on. It was clear it wasn’t their first time. I found out months later that Jennifer and Amy were sisters. I never told Jennifer and I don’t think Jennifer knows I am aware that they are sisters. Till today I don’t even know her sister’s real name. It was nice to be honest. It’s sad I came once. 

This article is based on real-life events. Names used are mere pseudonyms to protect the identities of the individuals mentioned in the report.

Interested in sharing your story with Culture Custodian? Kindly send an email to submissions@culturecustodian.com